| My Kindle |
|
I am a voracious, if slow reader.
I may spend as much as 8 hours in a day just reading.
That doesn’t happen every day, maybe 1 in 7; however I
always want to have a good reading library at hand at all times.
However, books take up space and don’t seem to like the warm,
moist climate most of us choose to cruise in. |
|
|
I always have a small library of paperbacks
and hard-bound books on board. Some of the books are for
reference (e.g., cooking and engine repair), and are a
semi-permanent library. Others are for general
reading and are acquired through book
exchanges at marinas or just through other cruisers.
Unfortunately the books available from these sources are
determined by the preferences of the other book-reading
cruisers. My
observations of the book exchanges I’ve experienced over the last
5 years tells me two things:
- There are a lot of woman cruising
these day. That’s a
good thing. The
downside is that the book exchanges seem to be over-stocked
with Chick-Books.
- Men on cruising boats seem to be
Sci-Fi readers.
Those two observations don’t produce a lot
of books that I want to read.
So I’ll keep participating in book
exchanges, but I need another source of reading material.
|
| In July, 2009 I purchased a Kindle II from Amazon.com as
potentially that other source. |
| Kindle Overview |
|
The
Kindle is an eBook device from Amazon.com.
It provides storage and display of hundreds of books,
periodicals and documents.
Books and periodicals are purchased through Amazon.com, documents can
also be from your computer. It is an amazing
device.
This is the Kindle II, which has a 6"
diagonal screen.
Amazon.com also offers the Kindle DX, which
has 9.7" diagonal screen and allows your to rotate the display
between portrait and landscape orientations.
I decided to go with the II rather than the
DX primarily because the DX is almost $200 more expensive ($489
vs. $299). I wasn't sure how good the market was for these
devices on eBay should I decide it wasn't really what I need.
|
| As of the original date I created this page I
had owned the Kindle for only a short time. In that time I'd
read two books. Actually that's really not a short time as
I'm a really sloooow
reader. It's been about a month. I'll use this page
to document my experience with the device and my evaluation of
how well it meets my needs. |
| What I Intend For My Kindle |
|
My Kindle will be a repository for those
books and documents that are not generally or immediately
available from book exchanges, fellow cruisers or English
language books stores overseas.
Most of the Kindle titles will be non-fiction which is
poorly represented in book exchanges or books on subjects in
which I am particularly interested, and I don’t want to wait
until a title shows up in a book exchange. Also I may
purchase books from my favorite authors shortly after they are
initially published. The Kindle will also reduce the
physical size of my book library in a similar way the
iPod
reduced the physical size of my music library.
When I depart on my next cruise I will load
up the Kindle with books of this kind.
I will still frequent book exchanges and
English language book stores and will maintain a small library
of paper backs and hardbound books on board.
|
| Pros and Cons |
Given my limited experience with this device (less than 6
months) one shouldn't take my list of Pros and Cons too seriously
at this time. However these are my observations at this
moment.
BTW, if these observations and opinions are not correct or
ill-informed, I would appreciate hearing from other Kindle users
to correct the lists. |
| PROs, not necessarily in order of
importance. |
-
Very
easy to use and easy to read.
I have found the Kindle very easy to operate.
I can increase the font size to the point where I
don’t need to use my reading glasses. The picture on
the right is of my Kindle with the font set to a size I can
comfortably read with my drug store glasses. I could
actually reduce the font and still read this text with my
glasses. Reducing the font puts more text on the
screen and minimizes the number of time you have to change
pages. Changing pages is the only time the Kindle uses
battery power (other than when connected to the wireless
network).
|
I
can increase the font size from that in the picture above.
The current font is the medium size for the display. |
Now
I have increased the the font to the second largest, which I can
read comfortably without those damned glasses. The picture
is a little fuzzy because I didn't hold the camera very still.
It is not caused by the Kindle. |
- (For me) Easier to read than a book, or maybe
just easier on the book. The Kindle can be
held and read with one hand. Books can be read with
one hand until you need to turn a page. With a Kindle
the page controls are on the left and right side of the
unit, so no matter which hand you use to hold it you can
turn the page with just the thumb on that hand. I'm
right-handed so I do have to juse my other hand to backup a
page. Using the menu (turning to the Table of
Contents, or to a bookmark) does require both hands.
Of course the twitter-generation will probably figure out a
way to do that with one hand.
I can lay the Kindle flat on a desk or table and still read
it with no hands and not lose my place. This is useful
when I'm using a reference book to aid in doing something
else (e.g., working with a computer program). With a
book I usually have to place a weight on the pages to keep
it in one place (unless I've already broken the back of the
binding). I wish more of the technical references I
use in computer work were available on the Kindle (although
this has been mitigated by Kindle support for
pdf
format documents).
Also, when reading a book on the Kindle I don't risk
breaking the binding when I put it down temporarily.
Usually I just lay the book open-side down to save my place,
which puts pressure on the binding. Nor do I have to
dog-ear a page to save my place. I try to use
bookmarks, but they never seem to be within reach when I
want to put the book down.
- Long battery
life (if wireless turned off).
I don't really know how long it will last.
I usually plug it into an outlet after having read a
book. With the
wireless on the battery appeared to run down in about 3 or 4
hours, but I didn’t keep track.
I only turn on the wireless when I need to access the
Kindle Store.
|
- Huge library
of books available.
I think Amazon.com is currently (2009) offering over
300K titles.
|
- Reasonable
price on books.
Most current edition books sell for $9.99, cheaper
than the paper back version at most bookstores. Around
2010 Amazon.com raised the price on most recently published
books to $12-$15.
|
- Can be read
in direct sunlight.
The screen is not an LCD, it does not depend on
backlighting.
|
- Don’t need to
use the PC or MAC to order/download books.
The Kindle is a wireless device and will connect
directly to the Kindle Store.
|
- The Kindle
can hold many documents at one time.
It will hold over 1,500 books. I expect to be
able to load it with enough books to provide reading
material for a 1 year cruise or longer.
|
- Works that
have been read can be archived to Amazon.com and retrieved
to the Kindle at a later date.
No need to clutter up the index with books I have
already finished, but I can always go back and read them
again.
|
- Books can be purchased Worldwide. In
recent (December, 2009) advertising Amazon.com has stated
that books now can be purchased and downloaded worldwide.
When I purchased my Kindle it was restricted wireless
connections from within the USA. Turns out it still
is. The Amazon.com advertisement is for a different
product Kindle(Global Wireless) and my Kindle has now been
re-branded as Kindle(U.S. Wireless). The Kindle(Global
Wireless) is a new product targeted for customers outside of
the USA or US residents who frequently travel outside of the
USA. However through the Kindle for PC software
described below, I found I can
purchase reading material outside of the US. It just
takes a few extra steps. In 2010 the product offerings
were upgraded to offer a WIFI only version and a
WIFI/Wireless version. The wireless version works
globally, but additional charges for purchases outside of
the USA may be incurred.
|
- Multiple Kindles on a Single Account. You
can have up to five Kindles on a single Amazon.com account,
all of which can concurrently read any of the books in the
account. Thus a family or group can share their Kindle
books.
|
-
Can Display Documents in Other Formats.
You
are not limited to just the documents and books purchased
and downloaded from the Kindle Store. With the latest
version of the Kindle firmware (2.3) The Kindle will display
documents in a number of different formats, the two most
useful for me are pdf and MS Word. When I learned this
I quickly transfered a couple of pdf files on my computer to
my Kindle (see below).
However the pdf files were not listed in the Kindle Home
Page. Checking back on the firmware update
announcement I found the small print. Although the
firmware update will take place automatically when I connect
my Kindle to the Kindle Store, not all Kindles will be
updated at once. That took a few more weeks
before my Kindle was updated and then I could upload pdf
files and read them on my Kindle. I can also display
these documents on my Kindle by converting them to the
Kindle format. This does involve a
few more
steps.
|
| CONs, not necessarily in order of
importance |
-
Cannot be read in
the dark.
The Kindle does not have a backlight on the screen, which
partially accounts for the long battery life. If I
want to read a Kindle book in the cockpit at night I will have to
wear one of my head lamps.
For night watches, in the
past, I've used audio books on
my iPod.
I can listen to a book being read while performing the
normal watch functions.
The Kindle does have an audio
capability - an electronic voice, which I have not tried.
I understand the audio runs down the battery pretty quickly.
However, audio books are pretty expensive on the iPod, so I
will likely give the Kindle audio capability a good test in
the future.
Recently, Amazon.com has been spinning the lack of a
backlight as a positive thing, citing a medical study
reported in the LA Times that found reading with a backlit
device just before going to sleep contributes to insomnia.
|
-
Amazon.com is the
only source of books.
A huge library, but still one source (see the Orwell
Fiasco, below). Amazon.com has announced that in late
2011 Kindles be able check out eBooks from some public
libraries. I'm not sure if my Kindle II will have that
capability. Probably requires the WIFI feature, which
is not part of the Kindle II configuration.
|
-
Graphics
are difficult to view.
This not a good medium for books that are richly
illustrated with detailed graphics.
There is a zoom feature, but on the initial books I
have read with detailed graphics the zoom did not provide
sufficient enhancement. The picture on the right is from the
Robert Perry book on yacht design. This is a graphic
rich book, with line drawings of many of Mr. Perry's
designs. These are the kind of graphics sailors, like
myself, love to gaze at for hours and investigate all of the
detail. Not much hope of that on this screen.
|
The
Kindle does have a zoom capability, but there is no capability
to magnify the graphic larger than the screen and then pan up
and down with scroll bars or the cursor to view the graphic in
detail.
The picture on the left shows the graphic from the Perry book
zoomed to fill the screen. It is still of no value.
Of course I don't own the printed version of this book.
Maybe the graphic was unreadable in that format as well.
I should have saved my money on the Perry book.
Coffee-table books are not a good choice for the Kindle.
Still I enjoyed the narrative, this is a very interesting book
for we sailors.
It does not appear that the Kindle will replace any of the
physical books in my on board reference library. |
-
The “Orwell
Fiasco”. In
July, 2009 Amazon.com discovered that the publisher from
whom they obtained copies of many of the works of George
Orwell (e.g., 1984) did not actually have the rights to
those works. Another
publisher did.
Amazon.com handled this situation in precisely the opposite
way it should have been handled – they made it their
customers' problem. Amazon.com deleted the works from
the accounts of those who had purchased the works and
refunded the purchase price, without notifying anyone of the
issue. These works
suddenly disappeared from those persons' Kindle the next
time they connected to the Kindle Store.
All annotations made by the users to those works also
disappeared. For
some people those annotations were the basis of a thesis or
student paper they were preparing.
The proper way to have handled this was for Amazon.com to
negotiate with the two publishers to protect the rights of
the customers who purchased the works.
If that failed then notify the users that within x
days the rights to those works would be rescinded so they
could preserve any notes and annotations made on their
Kindle.
It would appear Amazon.com management let their lawyers
dictate their actions – always a sign of poor management.
This incident happened a few weeks after I purchased
my Kindle. If it had
happened before that purchase I would likely not own a
Kindle for some time, if at all.
Amazon.com has promised to handle this type of
situation differently in the future and not remove any book
from a persons account without first notifying them.
|
-
The device is not
inexpensive.
My Kindle cost $300 – a fairly expensive, if tiny bookshelf.
The price now (December, 2009) is $260. In 2011 the
price has dropped to $139 with advertisements on the screen
saver or $189 with no adverts.
|
-
You cannot share
(i.e., exchange) books with other Kindle owners.
No Kindle swap meets.
So nearly every item on the Kindle will cost at least
$10. There are
a number of Public Domain works that are free, but other
large books may cost more than $10 (e.g., the Perry book on
yacht design).
I did recently learn from another Kindle user that there is
a limited sharing ability with the Kindle - within a single
Amazon.com account. Each account can have up to 6
Kindles, each of which can concurrently read any of the
books purchased in the account. So sharing is possible
within a family or group, but not with strangers (unless you
want them to have access to your account).
In 2011 I learned that some books can be loaned to other
Kindle users that are not on the same account.
Currently (2011) that loan is limited to 2 weeks, and only
for books whose publisher allows it. Very few of the
books in my Kindle library can be loaned out.
|
-
Battery Meter Not Reliable:
Although the battery discharges very slowly (when not
online), the little meter at the top of the screen that is
supposed to show the amount of charge remaining is not very
accurate. On several ocaisions I have started reading
with the meter showing the battery was only half-discharged,
then less than 10 minutes later I get the warning that the
battery is nearly dead and must be recharged. I
suspect that the meter takes several minutes of operation
before it registers accurately. I have lots of other
battery-powered electronics whose meters are accurate within
a few seconds of operation - e.g., my Sony and Fugifilm
digital cameras. This may be a function of the
batteries chosen for use in the Kindle, which may have been
dictated by the Kindle form factor.
- Not Indestructive:
I
have a tendency to fall asleep when reading. With a
book this meant dropping the book on the floor and losing my
place. At worst the book back is broken, but it still
can be read. With the Kindle I'm dropping a piece of
electronics. The Kindle is a reasonable well-made and
durable product, but it was not designed to be dropped
reapeatedly on the floor. Often the plastic backing on
the top of the Kindle would pop off. Initially I could
just push it back on, but then one time something was bent
or deformed when it hit the floor, and the backing would not
seal up with the front of the Kindle. The picture on
the right shows the gap between the front and back of my
Kindle. The Kindle still works just fine, but I'm sure
this gap will allow moisture and dirt to work its way into
the electronics and a failure is not that far off. Oh
well, the newer Kindles are cheaper, smaller and lighter
than my Kindle II, so I may buy myself one for Christmas or
my next birthday.
|
| Kindle for PC |
Recently (Nov 19, 2009) I downloaded the Kindle for PC
application. This program replicates the Kindle on a PC
screen and is synchronized with my Kindle library.
The
first book I opened with Kindle for PC is the Robert Perry book
whose illustrations were all but unviewable on the Kindle II.
This screen capture on the left is of the same page as
shown on the Kindle above. The
monitor on this laptop is fairly large (1680x1050) and when the
program window is maximized it appears at least as wide as a
large format coffee table book. Since I don't have the
original printed book for comparison, I'm only guessing on this.
However I believe the graphics as presented by Kindle on PC are
about the same size as those in the printed edition. These
are very detailed drawings, reduced significantly to fit on the
printed page, so a lot of detail was probably lost on printed
edition as well
In any case I can now see the detail in these drawings that was
lost when viewing them on the Kindle II. Amazon.com is
also promising to provide a zoom capability to Kindle for PC.
That tool would undoubtedly remove any differences between the
graphics in the printed edition and the e-book edition. It
actually might provide more detail than the printed edition. |
| I didn't bother to read the terms of use for Kindle for PC
before starting to use (not really a good idea given the Orwell
Fiasco). I was pleasantly surprised to discover that I
have access to all of the books in my account simultaneously on
both the Kindle II and my PC. I thought I might have to
juggle the books back and forth if I was restricted to a single
readable copy, which is not the case. Turns out the Kindle
for PC software is just one of the several Kindles allowed for my
account. |
| Kindle for PC will also allow me to purchase and read books
while I am out of wireless phone range and I cannot access the
Kindle Store with the Kindle II. |
|
Transfering Documents From My PC and My Kindle |
|
In December, 2009 I started experimenting with transferring
documents from my PC to my Kindle. There were a number of
reason I want to be able to do this.
- To purchase and download books from the Kindle Store
when I cannot connect with the Kindle (e.g., when outside of
the USA)
- To access documents on my computer in their native
format (e.g., pdf, MS Word, etc.)
- To convert documents from their native format to the
Kindle format.
|
One
thing the Kindle appears to have copied from the iPod is the use
of a single cable for charging from an AC outlet and for
connecting to a PC USB port. In the picture on the left I
have removed the AC plug from the cord, which reveals the USB
plug, and I have connected the Kindle to my computer. |
When
the Kindle is connected it goes into USB Drive Mode and acts
like another USB drive to the computer. As the screen
caption in the picture on the right says, I can use the Kindle
to read documents while connected by ejecting the Kindle drive
on my computer. Then the Kindle can be used while it
re-charges the battery via the USB port.
However, I want to transfer documents to my Kindle, so I'll
leave it connected as a USB Drive. |
On
my computer the Kindle appears as Drive: Kindle(G) at the bottom
of the Windows Explorer screen capture on the left. There
are three folders on this drive, Audio, documents and music.
At this time I am only interested in the documents folder.
That is where the Kindle documents reside. At the other
end of the arrow is the folder My Kindle Content under the My
Documents folder. This folder contains the documents that
are currently being used by the Kindle for PC software.
I can add or remove documents from both my Kindle and the Kindle
for PC software by dragging and dropping them between folders on
my PC.
However, until my Kindle firmware is upgraded to version 2.3 the
only documents I can view on the Kindle are those in Kindle
format.
So for now if I want to be able to read a pdf document on my
Kindle the document must first be converted to Kindle format.
Fortunately Amazon.com provides a free conversion service for
most of the common formats. There is a charge to download
a converted file to the Kindle via the wireless connection
($0.15/MB I believe), but this charge can be avoided by
downloading the converted file to the PC and then uploading it
to the Kindle. |
|
Converting
Documents to Kindle Format |
| Each Kindle registered with Amazon.com has a unique
identifier. That identifier appended to @kindle.com
provides the email address for the Kindle device. When an
email sent to that address with a file attached (or a zip file
containing multiple files) Amazon.com will convert the
files (if possible) and place them in the Kindle account for
download on the next connection. There is a fee for this
service. |
There
is an alternative address @free.kindle.com, which provides the
converted file for download to the PC rather than directly to
the Kindle. In the email on the right I have sent a copy
of the ICOM M802 SSB Radio manual to the free conversion
address. |
After
the conversion process was complete I received the email on the
left which contains a link to download the converted file. |
Once
the file has been downloaded I can then use Windows Explorer to
drag and drop the converted file to the documents folder on the
Kindle drive. |
After
I ejected the Kindle from the PC the ICOM manual now appears in
the Kindle home page. |
I can
read the manual on my Kindle. This manual was originally
in a PDF format, but the Kindle conversion can handle many
formats. On some of my own PDF documents I've found the
conversion process is not very clean. This may be due my
using a PDF file creator from other than Adobe. The Kindle
conversion process does an excellent job with the original MS
Word documents from which I created the PDF files.
While the current firmware in my Kindle can read PDF files in
their native format, they are much more readable if converted to
Kindle format. |
|
Bottom Line |
| After over 2 years of using the Kindle II, I
will never give it up except to purchase a newer, better
eReader. Most likely that will be another Kindle as the
PROs definitely out weigh the CONs for me. I have no
interest in a color eReader (with a backlit display) nor a
multi-function display such as the iPad. I might buy an
iPad, but not as a replacement for my Kindle. |